February 10, 2012

Mail Bag – How Does Someone Start Creating Passive Income?

Among the thousands of emails and messages I receive regularly, I came across one today that was sent to me on May 17th by Cale P. Here is the question that was posed:

I’m a pretty talented IT professional with great salary and a standard quality of living. I’ve known that I won’t be in IT for my whole career, at least I hoped. I have a natural ability to invent and I really would love to own private business(es) to see my decisions in a company flourish.

However, I’m unsure of how or when I will be able to reach my goal. I’m busy investing my savings to build my portfolio now. This includes dabbling in the stock market as of right now instead of full on investing. Mostly, I’ve just been saving bulk amounts of cash other than my investment in my home.

How should I, being someone who has a great deal of common sense but no college education in business, pursue owning a company? I could go into much more explanation like my career vs business but I would like to see if I can start the conversation before I write more. :)

The Rich Diversity of Cash-Generating Assets

It doesn’t necessarily require a formal education to become successful, but it does help.  Something north of 90% of self-made millionaires are college graduates, but that still means 1 out of every 10 have no college education.

That said, when we talk about “cash-generating assets” we aren’t just talking about businesses or stocks. The world is full of things that make your richer just by owning them because they throw off cash. The perfect cash-generating asset is one that produces a stream of money for you and your family to spend or reinvest and that increases its value every year to maintain pace with inflation. There are members of my own extended family that made money by owning car washes and storage units but no stocks. Still others invested everything in stocks and bonds. All ended up wealthy, but they chose different paths due to their own individual talents, experience, and risk tolerance.

There are countless asset types that can produce passive income. As you learned in the article on the Capitalist Class that I wrote for About.com, a division of The New York Times, to be a member of this economic rank requires at least $35,000 per month in passive income. It doesn’t matter if those earnings come from stocks, bonds, hotels, movie theaters, ice cream stands, song copyrights, book copyrights, patent licenses, sales commissions from a networking business model such as Avon or Mary Kay, or shares of a privately held family business.

In my own case, I start by asking one very, very important question …

What product or service can I give the world that will solve a need or want it has and for which it will be willing to pay me the most money for the least amount of work or investment on my part?

A Case of an IT Investment in My Own Life

Passive Income from Computers Have Changed the World in the Past 20 Years

This project allowed us to collect a "royalty" on sales generated by a business in which we had to invest no money of our own and where we have no day-to-day responsibilities.

In my own life, I have used information technology to create streams of income.  A few months ago, Kennon Green Enterprises, LLC approached a local manufacturing firm and struck a deal where we created the online ordering platform for their clients and, in exchange, we were paid 5% of sales.  Every day I wake up, we are collecting an on-going fee of 1 penny for every 20 pennies the company generates in sales.  That means for every $1,000,000 million in revenue they generate, we get $50,000 that has virtually no cost against it. Our total financial investment was less than $500 but we had the experience to put a system like that together.  The system wasn’t fully operational until a couple of weeks ago, but I expect we will report six-figures in taxable profit from this one operation in fiscal 2010.  It literally brings in money as we sleep.

This has been one of my favorite streams of earnings because it represents how using a specific knowledge base can result in a win-win for everyone involved.  It took us less than a month of work and yet we will now collect huge profits.  This is a “business” in a sense, but there are virtually no downsides.  We have very little money invested, only time and talent.

The idea came to me as I was drinking coffee and reading a magazine, while Aaron played The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess.  It didn’t require us to take out loans or risk our own capital.  That is what I mean when I say a “perfect” cash generator.  If the project failed, we weren’t out much, yet if it succeeded, it could have a big influence on our net worth due to the power of compounding.

Not Everyone Should Operate a Business

Furthermore, just because someone is good at creating wealth with one asset type does not automatically mean they will do well in another; e.g., someone who made hundreds of millions of dollars investing in technology patents because of an engineering background may be terrible when it comes to choosing individual stocks for his portfolio.  Doctors are notorious for making horrific investments because their skill set in medicine doesn’t translate in any way, shape, or form into finance.

Some People Just Cannot Run a Company Without Losing Money

McDonald's Franchise

For some investors, a McDonald's franchise would be an absolute gold mine that minted money for their family for decades because they are great operators. They know how to cut costs, increase sales, and manage employees. For others, it could be a huge disappointment and money losing disaster. Thus, you cannot ask, "Should I invest in a McDonald's franchise" any more than you could ask, "Should I become a professional golfer or a dentist?" It depends on your own strengths, talents, interests, and skills.

Consider the case of Warren Buffett. Although he was the greatest investor of the 20th century, Buffett was horrible at running a business himself. According to some reports, not only did he lose substantial money investing in a service station in Nebraska during his twenties, but also later, when he tried to run the insurance companies during Berkshire Hathaway’s formative years, he lost the company hundreds of millions of dollars. Thus, there seems to be strong evidence that if Warren were put in charge of the day-to-day operations of one of his business, such as the Borsheim’s jewelry store, it wouldn’t be successful for long. Still, Buffett amassed billions of dollars because he realized that he isn’t good at running a company. His strength lies in identifying and valuing great businesses and motivating the people who do the day-to-day work. By focusing on this one area, where he excels, he has built a reputation and record that will be studied for centuries.

Likewise, if you fall into this same category, attempting to buy a company and run it yourself could cause you to lose everything you invested (and potentially more). In our grandparent’s generation, they called a person that could run a company a great “operator”. Indeed, in his memoir, Dave Thomas, the founder of Wendy’s who dropped out of high school and amassed a nine-figure fortune, lamented that many great business leaders are not, in fact, great operators, and that is what it takes to run a business such as a restaurant or a retailer.

The heart of a good operator is someone who realizes that sales minus costs equal profit. They know how to find the right blend of revenue and profit margin to result in the highest possible return on equity. Sam Walton, for example, focused on making only a few pennies for every dollar in sales. His model was based upon huge volume that got the return on shareholders’ money as high as 60% during the expansion years of the 1960’s and 1970’s. Tiffany & Company, on the other hand, focuses on high profit margins and a more exclusive sales clientele. A good operator would be successful whether he or she was running either business.

If you don’t have that talent – the ability to count pennies and drive new business through the door – then owning something like a franchise might be a disaster for you because your success will come down to how effectively you can watch the bottom line, hire quality employees, and satisfy customer needs. You may be a brilliant accountant or investor but if you lack those specific skills, you are going to get your ass handed to you, for lack of a better phrase.

Others Make It Work for Them

In my hometown back in the Midwest, there is a lawyer that has a practice in criminal law.  He also used his earnings to buy control of a chain of ice cream businesses throughout the city.  Every day, as he is in the courthouse arguing cases, he and his family are bringing in sales from ice cream cones, banana splits, shakes, malts, and more.  My guess is the business is successful because he was able to use his job to get the company off the ground and he doesn’t need to “live out” of the earnings.  Any time you can hold something for investment and aren’t forced to use the money it generates to pay bills, your net worth is likely to expand faster.

Clearly, this lawyer knows how to manage sales and costs.  If he didn’t the chain of ice cream businesses would be bleeding money and he would have to cover the expense from his legal income.  For him, given his interests and talents, owning these frozen treat stands is a perfect business strategy that will help him grow wealthier.  For someone else, it would be an unmitigated disaster that could eat up all of their savings and force them into bankruptcy.  That is one of the reasons I cannot say, “Go buy a business!”  Some people have the skills, while others don’t.  History has shown that a well-run company, however, is a “gift that keeps on giving” in Buffett’s words. That is why I enjoy talking about them.

The Challenge Is Greatest at $5 Million and Below

Hotel Franchise

The most frustrating part for those starting out is that it can be difficult to raise money, borrow funds, and do substantial products until you reach the $5 million net worth figure, at which point it becomes far easier to access capital. Suddenly, big projects such as hotel ownership, franchise area developments, and a host of other opportunities become available almost overnight.

To make matters worse, the challenge is more difficult at $5 million or below, which is where virtually all self-made millionaires begin!  In other words, if you have $5 million in net worth, you could invest your assets into a mid-tier hotel franchise such as a Hampton Inn, then pay one of the handful of high-profile hotel management firms to manage your property in exchange for 5% of the revenue.  You are never going to have to step foot in your real estate and yet, provided you have a good location and management company, each year a stream of profits is going to be deposited into your bank account.

Options like that, which are so readily available for those with the money to hire quality people, aren’t available in the early days.  After all, it requires a special type of genius to be able to buy a hotel and grow it into a fortune.  A complete idiot, however, could inherit a property of hotel investments and live off the dividends they threw off annually.  Some commentators have theorized that money creates its own gravitational pull, just like a planet.  The more you have, and the larger your fortune, the more money gets attracted to it because you are presented with bigger and more lucrative opportunities.

(It is possible to do this on a smaller scale because you can hire single family or apartment building management companies.  There are some of these firms in small towns that will take care of choosing new tenants, signing leases, and much more for a pre-arranged fee and revenue sharing schedule.  That way, you just choose the individual investments but they take care of running them.  Sure, you are giving up more money, but if you aren’t an operator, that may be worth it.)

Know Thyself

With all of that said, if I were a regular employee trying to figure out where to begin creating passive income, I would ask myself several questions:

  • Do I have the skills or desire to become an operator?  Do I want to deal with choosing signage for a chain of ice cream stands or watching payroll costs for employees?  If not, owning and operating a business is out of the question.  If I am a good operator, the options become endless because I can do almost anything from investing in a new commercial office building to buying a set of waffle houses.
  • Can I create assets that will generate cash?  I, for example, have tens of thousands of finance articles that generate thousands of dollars each month in royalties, as well as a book, etc.  These were created “out of thin air” in that they didn’t require any money to start generating cash, just my ideas and some time.  Barry Manilow is worth hundreds of millions of dollars now, but he started by writing famous jingles for television products.  His earnings from these projects are what made him rich long before he was a hit songwriter.  He created something out of thin air and turned it into cash, which is really useful when you are starting without a lot of money.
  • Do I want to have to learn detailed accounting rules, how to value individual stocks, etc.?  If not, a better idea may be to create as much passive income as possible and on the equity portion of your portfolio, dollar cost average into low-cost index funds.  Over decades, you, effectively, could ignore the volatility and compound your money at somewhere between 7% and 11% if history is any guide.  Thus, it would serve as an augment to your cash generators; a way to inventory profits, as it were.

Of course, I have a lot to say about stocks and bonds, but until the question of “are you an operator” is answered, it is pointless to discuss.  So, I put that out there: Are you an operator?

Related posts:

  1. Mail Bag: How to Create Passive Income If You Have Little or No Money or Connections
  2. Mail Bag – Do You Have Any Regrets?
  3. Passive Income Asset Allocation Model Portfolio
  4. Mail Bag – Why Wouldn’t Someone Sell an Overvalued Stock?
  5. Mail Bag – Taking on a Small Business Partner for a Startup
  6. Mail Bag – Once You Become Rich, How Should You Handle People That Wouldn’t Give You the Time of Day in the Past?
  7. Mail Bag: You Are A Narrow Minded Prick
  8. Mail Bag – What Drives Successful People and How Do You Overcome Discouragement?
  9. Mail Bag: Why Did You Switch Your Company to Mac from Windows?
  10. Mail Bag – Opportunity Cost and Enjoying Your Money

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=558200020 Christopher C Goorts

    This question has probably been asked a million times, but i believe you wrote that in your college years, you made passive income via an online business, am I correct?

    Have you written any articles on how you started said business, and your first experiences with online business?

    I am asking because, I too am a university student at the moment, and I’ve looked into doing this for a very long time. I have been reluctant to do so, since I’m not sure how to go about doing it and have never met anyone with real-life experiences doing it.

    by the way, I’ve had a smorgasbord with you articles today, very informative stuff, thanks for this valuable knowledge.

    • http://www.joshuakennon.com Joshua Kennon

      Christopher,

      I’m so sorry I never responded to this. Your comment somehow slipped under the radar.

      It’s hard to say because so much of it depends upon your own strengths. My brother, for example, could probably start and run a paintball retailer and blog and make money at it within a few years, perhaps enough to do it full time. I know nothing about it so I couldn’t, despite my knowledge of business in general. So a lot of success comes down to specific knowledge in a field.

      I’d start by asking yourself: What do you know more than anyone else? If you don’t have an answer to that, I’d try and discover: What niche product isn’t being covered by a lot of people but offers a chance for high profit margins? A few years ago, I read about a guy who was selling a specific type of power generator online and was making six-figures a year doing it because they were needed by some industry and nobody else even knew what they were so there was only one online store for it! That is the sweet spot of commerce. If you can get enough lead time, you can use the profit to build your moat. In that case, you would KEEP YOUR MOUTH SHUT AND NEVER TELL ANYONE YOUR BUSINESS! Seriously, you would want it to be a secret as long as possible, no matter how much you wanted to brag.

      If I had to start over again tomorrow, I’d probably find some distributor, swing a deal to develop a site for them, and be able to use all of their niche inventory, capturing a percentage of the profit but using their investment in inventory. Or I’d become obsessed with selling 1,000 cashmere scarves for $100 each that I paid $5 to import, giving me $95,000 in pre-tax profit to serve as my startup capital. But that’s just me based upon my own experiences and knowledge.

      So the question is: What do you know about? If nothing, start researching to find the most profitable ideas you can that require very little financial risk on your part. You want to be in businesses that if you make a mistake, you aren’t financially destroyed.

  • calegp

    Joshua,

    Thank you so much for this article, it was very helpful. Everything that you have written has been wonderful to read. It has really been able to solidify some of my thoughts and has been a great help. If you are like me, this makes you feel accomplished so I want to be sure you are getting that feeling.

    I finally wrote on my confusion and why I asked this question. Hopefully, I will have the desire to write more and get more help on clearing my mind.

    http://www.calegp.com

    Thanks again!
    Cale

    • http://www.joshuakennon.com Joshua Kennon

      Hey, Cale. I just noticed this comment hadn’t been approved because of the filter that is in place (the first comment of a registered user has to be approved to stop spam, after which they have posting privileges.) Sorry I missed this one – I just approved it. I’m glad you liked the article! – Josh

      • Kai

        Joshua as usual great article man. I live in new jersey and I wish I was had run across your site or you when you were in college in here because I would have definitely loved to come across someone who thinks just like I do,  I have literally spent hours of work time ( selling my labor time lol ) to read your work, but dont worry I dont do it enough to get in trouble lol. I’m 25 so I’m kind of late to the party of starting my asset grab, but I’ve been studying to be a value investor for sometime. As far as skills, I’m a musician/ singer with a degree in Finance and IT,  but if I had to choose ( apart from owning assets that throw off cash, looking at reports and value investing ) I’d love to wake up every morning and create music. I haven’t had the experience of being an operator either so I honestly dont know if I’d be good at it, but I know that I can do anything over the net.  So I’d like to get started ASAP getting that all elusive first 100k that Charlie Munger always talks about. 

        Thanks for your insight,

        Kai

        • Joshua Kennon

          Kai,

          For the past few months, I’ve been meaning to respond to the message you submitted through the contact form.  I remember it because of the similarity in our backgrounds.  I just keep falling behind and since the site is a hobby, it sometimes gets put on the back burner so I apologize for taking so long.  The irony is, it took so long because I kept thinking, “No, I want to actually write a real response to him” so it kept getting put off.  

          First, welcome to the site!  If anything I write helps you achieve whatever your dreams are, I’ll consider my time enormously well spent.  There is no reason you can’t ultimately get into that position.  The question will be, “How much income do you require to have the lifestyle you desire?”.  If you only need $50,000 per year, all it would take is a $500,000 row of townhouses or something comparable and you are now a full-time musician living off a private income.  If you want, instead, $200,000 a year, it is a different story.  It’s all up to your personality and own desires.

          Speaking of our shared backgrounds, I’m actually putting in a music room at home.  I missed composing and practicing like my college days so I wanted a space that had nothing but a grand piano, bookcases of sheet music, a computer system with Finale and recording software, and piles of staff paper.  I’ve toyed with releasing some of the stuff on iTunes under a secret label I setup for fun.  It’s so easy to get a distributor for the Apple store anymore, Aaron keeps saying we should just do it for fun at the office, not tell anyone, and get it out of our systems.  

          I’d be almost just as happy being a video game composer as I would be an investor.  Right now, I’m enamored with The Waterfalls of Agharata, which was published on the Castlevania: Lords of Shadow official soundtrack as part of the re-launch of that game franchise.  You can listen to it at http://youtu.be/GmUZ8B2pgAc

  • http://janechin.com Jane Chin, Ph.D.

    Excellent article, Joshua, full of examples and concluded with key lessons. Another reason why I come back time and again to read your blog.

    • Joshua Kennon

      Thank you, Jane.  That was very kind. I’m glad you found it useful.