May 25, 2013

I Just Realized My Elementary School Curriculum Committee Was Made Up Of Geniuses

Growing up, I remember sitting in a tiny farm down of a few thousand people in the middle of Missouri – thousands of miles from the ocean – and having to learn about tsunamis.  The lessons were integrated so we had to know how to spell it on the spelling test, we had to know how they had hurt different societies in the past through death and devastation for history and social studies, and we had to know the causes and warning signs for science.

It was fascinating to me that a tsunami could appear as an ordinary wave in the depth of the ocean – and that you were safest out in the water if you were far enough away from land – otherwise you needed to be on the highest, most stable ground you could find.  The paradox of that stuck with me.  Who’d have thought the safest place against water was floating on top of the deepest water you could find?  It make sense.

I have no idea why this was part of our education, especially given that we were nowhere near the Atlantic or Pacific, but it was drilled into this small nine year old boy a couple of decades ago.  I can still see the page on the textbook, which I know now is a famous Ukiyo-E of the 19th century called In the Hollow of a Wave off the Coast at Kanagawa By Hokusai (1760-1849).

So when I see the video like this – the boats capsized on the beach and the piers now as tall as trees – every fiber of my being screams, “RUN!” – even though there are no visible warning signs that would indicate mass death and destruction is about to follow.  

This caused me to reflect.  That same year, we also learned efficient farming methods to prevent crop death and erosion.  I can still see the test paper – it was blank, with boxes, and cartoon outlines of hills on a farm.  We had to draw the different planting methods based on the soil analysis and rain patters (e.g., swirling from the top of the hill, instead of planting in long lines over the hill, can result in greater top soil retention, how to properly fertilize soil, the importance of cover crops, how to create lines of trees as windbreakers to protect the more lucrative harvests).

And we were taught to look for signs of animal behavior changes – if you suddenly find yourself in an area where the birds have disappeared, or its gone quiet, pay attention.  Though no empirical proof has been found due to the impractical nature of studying such a phenomenon, anecdotal evidence throughout history has indicated that certain types of earthquakes might have signs that different animals can sense before humans.  

(The most famous case is the 1975 earthquake in Haicheng city.  In the months leading up to the quake, there were constant reports of bizarre animal behavior.  Officials were hesitant to do anything but then a small series of tremors hit and, better safe than sorry, the city was emptied.  The next day, a 7.3 magnitude quake hit.)  If you’re home alone and the dog starts suddenly growling at the back door, you might grab a gun and call the police.  That sort of thing.  Be aware of your surroundings and don’t rely solely on your own sense.  In this same tsunami video, that means when you saw the locals run, you should be running, too.  Ask questions on the way.

We were also forced to learn sailor maxims to predict weather such as, “Red sky at night, sailor’s delight.  Red sky in morning, sailor’s warning.”

I have no idea what the curriculum committee was thinking.  While everyone else was trying things like new math and “everybody gets a medal”, we were doing integrated, reinforcing lesson plans mixed with real-world, practical knowledge.  And there was competition.  Once a year, the entire school shut down for a “field day” where they handed out blue ribbons for first, red ribbons for second, and green ribbons for third place based on a wide variety of athletic challenges.  It was so much fun.  It had a celebration-like atmosphere.  That was the first time I remember thinking, “Yeah … I have no advantage at this whole rope climbing thing but I’m awesome at the intellect stuff.  I should probably focus on it.”

They were either visionary geniuses or there was an eccentric on the planning board who somehow attained power while no one was watching.

I can see the meetings now:

George: “They must learn about tsunamis!”  

Martha: “But George, we’re 2,000 miles away from the ocean in the middle of the plains.”

George: “You never know.  Better safe than sorry.  Martha, put tsunamis on the list!”

Martha: “Should that go before or after the discussion about small pox being able to adhere to the fibers of certain blankets?”  

George: “Come on Martha, this is a no brainer.  Put it after animal husbandry and the discussion of hermaphrodites in Ancient Egypt.”

  • Anon

    You should check out a movie playing in theaters called The Impossible.

  • Gilvus

    I recall you blogging about how the public school system was terrible (maybe it was Kansas instead of Missouri?), so your parents hired a retired teacher to tutor you, even when they were cash-strapped. I wouldn’t put it past your school to have brilliant directors and teachers who understand epistemology and how to engage students, but maybe the tsunamis were simply required in the standards of the time. Maybe it was government-mandated teaching objectives?

    • http://www.joshuakennon.com/ Joshua Kennon

      No, the story you are thinking of is when I was still in pre- pre-school age. Around 3 or so my parents sent me to a retired teacher to give me a huge head start. She taught us to read and we had all sorts of adventures in our little class, like learning how to use a ruler and stuff. It was a huge advantage because by the time I entered the public school system, I was years ahead. Looking back, my parents should have just had me skip a few grades because I (foolishly) never said anything but sat there, did the work, and used my spare time to read whatever else interested me. My life turned out great, though, so I can’t complain. Who knows where I would be or what I would be doing had that not happened.

      The school district in which I grew up was good in a lot of ways, but the Kansas City district is the worst in the nation. I also have several friends who are teachers and one of the districts in the suburb where I live now is so bad that they had to use picture books instead of reading advanced novels in high school (I’m working on a post about that last one).

      • Gilvus

        That last part makes me want to crawl into a corner and ferment. Is it a lack of funding? Is it NCLB? Is it poorly run? Does the state just keep pushing education down its priority list?

        • weixiluo

          Schools, nowadays, are forced to teach to the lower-performing students, and although it may have some advantages, in overall I think it just makes the complete education system weaker. Good and/or motivated students will learn most of their knowledge outside schools, leaving the weaker/less motivated students struggling even more inside schools with teachers desperately trying to make them learn, causing a vicious circle… Thoughts?

        • Gilvus

          Teaching to the lowest common denominator, I feel you. I taught a science class for a few semesters, and tailored my lessons so the majority of my students could keep up. Problem is – the sharper, motivated students got bored at the pace, while the slower and/or slackers who don’t go to lecture couldn’t keep up. And I was just a TA for grad school – I can’t imagine how teachers do this for a lifetime career.

          I’m not aghast at the condition of America’s education system (it’s not exactly a secret) as much as I’m surprised that this is happening in Joshua’s backyard. From the pictures he’s posted of his home, it’s not a mansion but it’s certainly not run-down or small. I would’ve guessed that the property taxes from his area would attract higher-quality teachers and better resources for students, that’s all. Plus, I never thought of KC as a terrible place for education. Hell, I spent a large number of my formative years in Mississippi, so I assumed Kansas/Missouri was at least average.

          That’s why I’m guessing it has to do with mismanagement and close-mindedness. IIRC, a school board out of Kansas was the reason the Flying Spaghetti Monster was created as a mockery of the board’s circular logic.

        • http://www.joshuakennon.com/ Joshua Kennon

          Ah, I get the confusion. It’s a other-side-of-the-tracks situation. I bought my current house when I was younger (in my mid 20s) as a starter home, paid a bit more than $300,000 for it and then started writing checks to upgrade it so you’re correct about the sociodemographics of my area. It’s mostly accountants, doctors, lawyers, and professors. The schools right next to me are how you describe – far better than average, far better college graduate rates, and very good facilities.

          A couple of miles away, is the high school I’m going to write about. It used to be very good but it was supported by factories that went out over the past 20 years. Now, despite good funding and good teachers, the sociodemographics of the area just don’t care about education because of a policy called “social promotion”. My friends are furious about it because they have no choice but to pass students to the next grade level – it is almost impossible to stop it from happening.

          I’ll try and cover all that in the upcoming post. Just wait until I explain how they are treating literature and grammar. You can’t even imagine that policies that have been put in place … it gets worse, too. My part of town is planning on splitting the school district – or at least having discussions about it – into new schools so *our* kids don’t have to go to class with *their* kids. I’m not kidding. It’s … just wait for the post. There is so much folly and bad thinking that you’ll probably want to be sitting down when I talk about it.

        • Gilvus

          That sounds like everyone’s entitled to progress through the levels, even if they can’t handle new material built on what they should’ve already learned. I’m sure a lot of the decision-making is spurred by how NCLB handles the purse-strings as well…

          Okay, I’ll wait. I’ll be sure to remove all small fuzzy animals from my presence when you publish the post so I won’t get the urge to drop-kick them out of frustration.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=525700300 Jason Spacek

    Field days are sweet, man. My grade school hosted one every year at the end of the year.. everyone looked forward to it.

  • jen111

    You guys should google John Taylor Gatto for an interesting take on the US education system. If we had more teachers like Gatto, the education system would actually teach kids how to think and solve problems instead of mostly just encouraging rote memorization. Josh, your curriculum committee’s style having the teachers use a mixture of reinforcing lesson plans mixed with real-world, practical application sounds similar to Gatto’s creative, yet effective style. Gatto said he even rearranged the furniture in his classroom every day just to keep the kids’ senses alive. The kids actually looked forward to coming into his class every day just to see what type of new arrangement he had come up with.

    • jen111

      He also studied the curriculum of many private secondary boarding schools, many of which produce much of our national leadership, and found out the emphasis of the curriculum was entirely different from that of regular public schools.

    • jen111

      The whole education system needs complete overhaul and revamping. It’s old, out-dated, ineffective, creativity stifling, and seems like some form of punishment to the typical, restless kid. It’s about time they re-thought the whole thing.

      • Gilvus

        Hey Jen, you know you can edit your posts instead of replying to yourself, right? :-p And yes, a mass-produced education system sort of looks like this. Finland looks like a good place to start – teachers need to pass masters-level coursework and certification exams, and get paid very well for the hard work they do. The East Asian culture that promotes doing well in school (and bringing shame to the family if you don’t) produces lots of kids who are technically adept…but not very creative.

        • jen111

          Gilvus I have read some of your posts on here… you crack me up. lol