Margin of Safety

The Secret to Understanding the Value Investing Strategy

The single most important concept in all of investing, according to Benjamin Graham and later confirmed by his star student, Warren Buffett, comes down to three simple words: Margin of Safety.

What is the margin of safety?  How do you calculate it?  How important is it to developing a successful value investing strategy?  As you’ll see in a moment, the theory behind value investing is that the ultimate return you earn on your investments will be closely related to the size and quality of the margin of safety you build in to your purchasing decisions, whether you are buying shares of Coca-Cola or building a hotel.  By understanding the concept and, just as importantly, the reason great value investing practitioners have treated it as holy scripture throughout their career, you can better position yourself to utilize the strategy in your own day-to-day money management activities.

Value Investing Margin of Safety Defined

Benjamin Graham basically described the margin of safety for any asset to be the discount between your carefully and conservatively calculated “true” value of the business (often called “intrinsic value” of a company or assets) and the price you paid for that asset.  In other words, if you calculate that a building, company, or timber rights, for example, are worth $1,000,000 and you pay $600,000, your margin of safety is $400,000 ($1,000,000 intrinsic value – $600,000 purchase price = $400,000).

Graham borrowed the margin of safety concept for his value investing strategy from the engineering field.  He pointed out that if a bridge says it can handle a load of 10,000 lbs., it will have actually been constructed to handle, say, 15,000 lbs. or more.  This difference of 5,000 is the margin of safety to ensure that the bridge doesn’t collapse and kill someone if a stupid, inpatient driver decides to take a risk and drive his 10,200 lbs. truck onto the structure.  The bigger the margin of safety, the less risk involved for the truck driver, the city or county, and those standing by or who happen to be parked on the bridge or coming from the opposite direction.

Calculating Intrinsic Value of a Stock to Estimate the Margin of Safety

How would one go about calculating the estimated private market value or intrinsic value of an assets?  After all, without this knowledge, it’s impossible to calculate the margin of safety and value investing would be nothing more than speculation under the guise of academic guesswork.  There are several ways:

  • Compare the book value of a company to the current share price.  In some cases, the bigger the discount, the more substantial the margin of safety. Book value isn’t intrinsic value so you need to estimate how “real” you think each dollar of book value is.  For instance, if a poorly managed company had acquired only a single asset, say a hotel for which it paid $30 million that has fallen apart and has no chance of ever earning at least $3 million a year (a 10% capitalization rate), you would need to look very skeptically at the balance sheet book value estimate.  You wouldn’t want to pay $30 million for the entire company because it the book value, or net worth, of the firm isn’t really $30 million.  On the other hand, a company like Berkshire Hathaway has a book value that far understates the intrinsic value assigned by most value investing money managers because only a fraction of the company’s earnings power is visible on the income statement due to accounting rules.  In this case, buying Berkshire Hathaway at a discount to book value would represent a substantial margin of safety.
  • Look at the buyout multiples for comparable deals.  The smaller the multiple for a particular stock relative to its industry, the larger the margin of safety if the balance sheet is strong. If you have access to a Bloomberg terminal or other research service, look at the average multiple between the buyout price and the company’s earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT).  Of course, if you believe the market is in a bubble, this information may not be reliable.  In most markets, however, it is extremely useful because it shows you what real people are willing to pay for a business.  You should prefer “financial” buyers such as hedge funds because they don’t have any synergies from their core businesses, meaning they have the most conservative valuations relative to strategic buyers, which can wring out cost savings.  If most candy companies have been sold at multiples of 10x EBIT and you find a great candy business selling at 6x EBIT, your margin of safety is 4x EBIT.  That’s substantial and, at that level, almost any value investing firm would pick up shares for their account if the balance sheet was strong without a lot of debt.
  • Compare the dividend yield to the coupon rate of long-term United States Treasury bonds.  The bigger the difference in favor of the dividend, the larger the margin of safety. If a stock has a dividend payout ratio that is relatively low (say, under 50%), it is well protected and has little or no danger of becoming unsustainable, and the dividend offers a yield far higher than that of the 30-year United States Treasury bond, the stock may offer a huge margin of safety.  This is another type of stock that a lot of value investing firms would pick up for their account fairly quickly.
  • The more diversified a company’s revenue sources and assets, the bigger the margin of safety. Speaking of Berkshire Hathaway’s considerable energy holdings, Warren Buffett once remarked that there is often a larger margin of safety investing in a power company with plants spread across several states with a BB credit rating than it is buying shares of a power plant rated AAA yet operating from a single location, such as the company that serviced New Orleans before Katrina.  The margin of safety concept is supposed to be your protection.  No matter how strong the balance sheet, if all of the earning power originated from a single plant that could be taken under by a Category 5 hurricane, you have a very small margin of safety.  You would only want to risk a fraction of your capital – no more than 3% at most – and buy when the shares were undervalued according to some of the other metrics we’ve discussed here and in signs of a good value investing stock.

The Margin of Safety Is Supposed To Offer Some Protection (Which May Not Be Possible Depending Upon the Event) Against Black Swans and Over Confidence

Margin of Safety Value Investing with Ben Graham

The concept of the margin of safety, made famous by Benjamin Graham, the father of value investing, is that you should leave a buffer between your purchase price of an assets and the intrinsic value you calculate for that asset. Graham believed in knocking off 1/3 of the value. He borrowed the concept of the margin of safety from the engineering field, where a 10,000 pound capacity bridge may really be designed to carry 15,000 pounds. Image © iStockphoto/Thinkstock

The major advantage of building in a large margin of safety into every value investing position you add to your portfolio is that it can absorb mistakes if you turn out to be wrong.  Of course, none of us actually thinks that is a possibility, otherwise we wouldn’t be buying the shares of stock!  Nevertheless, things do happen.  Executives embezzle, audits fail, and major customers leave.  If things are merely mediocre, there’s a good chance you will have the opportunity to sell out at fair value, providing a nice return.  If things work out very well, you may hit the ball out of the park and get rich.  If things go south, your margin of safety can absorb some of the blow because the shares are already cheap.  At least, that is the theory behind value investing.  The future may be different from the past.

  • ALFREDO A ATWATER

    Hi Joshua :

    Can you help me solve this questions ?

    1 Regarding Coca Cola’s debt. Is it not too much debt the one Coca Cola carries ?

    Source : Value Line

    CAPITAL STRUCTURE as of 9/28/12 Total Debt $32.730 bill. Due in 5 Yrs. $16.1 bill. LT Debt $16.181 bill. Total Int. $400.0 mill. (Total interest coverage: greater than 30x)

    (33% of Cap’l) Pension Assets-12/11 $6.2 bill. Oblig. $8.3 bill.

    31944 30.3% 30.5% 31.4%

    1228.0 1236.0 1443.0 7050.0 6824.0 8144.0

    22.2% 22.8% 22.7%

    2. Is Carlos Slim the richest man on earth because he concentrates his investments although they may be riskier ?
    – It caught my attention to learn that Mr. Slim’s company America Movil operates in 29 countries. I guess that is part of his desire to create a worldwide monopoly network of telephone companies . What is your view ?

    3- What are the 10 commandments for you when you select a stock ?

    4- What would I have to study to determine intrinsic value, is it the financial statement and if it is the financial statement is the latest financial statement evaluation enough ?

    5- Do historic consistent earnings determine the moat of a company ?

    Thanks

    Fredy Atwater